The Hunt for Eric's New Car


I traded in my truck at the end of 2001 for a car. The truck had about 98,000 miles on it and was still running ok.  But, the ride and handling were not great, especially in the snow (I guess I should have bought the 4 wheel drive option). It was great in college when I moved frequently, but it was time for a vehicle that could handle the snow and seat more than 2 people.  I ended up with a Volkswagon Passat.

My Criteria

I test drove many vehicles, some just for fun.  Much to Lisa's dismay, test driving and talking about cars was a little hobby of mine for a couple of months.  I initially wanted a car with gas mileage of about 30 mpg in the city, with a high safety rating, with enough horsepower that the car doesn't feel like a weak 4 cylinder.  I also wanted a manual transmission, a station wagon (i couldn't go straight from a truck to a car :), a little style and luxury for around $20,000.  I wanted a good size compact to a mid-size, something sporty without being solely a sports car.

OK, maybe my requirements are a little unrealistic.  The only cars that get 30 mpg in the city are usually small, under powered compacts.  Cars that have plenty of power, usually have a V6 with more power than I needed, drink too much gas, and didn't come in a manual.  So, I knew right from the start that I was going to have to compromise on something.

The Cars I Drove

I drove many 2002 models: Volkswagon Jetta & Passat, Honda Accord, Toyota Camry, Nissan Sentra SE-R, Mazda Protege, Volvo V40, and the Subaru Impreza & Legacy.  I would have liked to drive a BMW, Audi, or some other sporty luxury car, but they were way out of the price range.  The reality that a luxury car was more than I wanted to spend started to settle in after I drove the Volvo.  


The Volvo V40 was around $25,000 but didn't come in a manual.  To add a few more options would have made it cost even more.  It was safe, handled great, good gas mileage, but overall it was a little bland and more than I wanted to spend.


The Impreza and Legacy were nice. Both cars handled well and came in manuals.  The Impreza was a little more exciting than the Legacy.  Since they both have all wheel drive, the gas mileage wasn't great.  The Impreza was in the running, but I thought that one of the options I wanted wasn't available.  All wheel drive wasn't a priority for me anyway.


The Mazda Protege 5 was cheap but nice.  I wasn't expecting much when I drove this car and I was pleasantly surprised.  When I drove it around the city, it handled far better than I thought it would.  It had a stiff sport suspension which I soon realized translated to a rough ride on the highway.  Sport suspensions are not my thing.  It could also have used just a little more horse power.  It probably didn't help that they didn't have a manual transmission for me to test drive.


Like the Protege, I wasn't expecting much from the Nissan Sentra SE-R. I've driven some of the older, standard Sentra's in the past.  Again, like the Protege, I was pleasantly surprised.  The Nissan Sentra SE-R had plenty of power and a sport suspension that wasn't too rough... although I didn't take it on the highway.  I drove this just for kicks since I knew that it wasn't really what I was looking for.


The Accord and Camry were nice.  Both had a plush ride.  A stark contrast to the cars with sports suspension that I drove, but both were just a little to plush for me.  I liked the handling of the Accord over the Camry, but the new Camry had better styling.  I didn't get a chance to drive the 4 cylinder Camry.  I drove the Camry and the Accord more for comparision with the Passat.


The Jetta and the Passat fit more of what I wanted in a car. More style than the Camry or the Accord.  Both cars had the same turbo 4 cyclinder engine, which had the amount of power that I was looking for with decent gas mileage. Both came in wagons with a manual transmission.  I went with the Passat because it handled a little better, was a little safer, and was more reliable. I threw in a few options (leather, cold weather package, etc.) which pushed the price up.  But with a little haggling I kept under $25,000.  I've put the spec's for the car at the bottom of this page.

What do I think so far?

I was happy with the car until the beginning of 2003.  The car started to lurch along the road and sounded terrible.  I managed to get the car to a dealer only to find out that this is a common problem on 2001 and 2002 VWs with 4 cyclinder turbo engines.  The coil pack has a defect that causes the cyclinder to mis-fire.  Since there is one coil pack per cyclinder, this problem could potentially happen to me 3 more times.  VW was having trouble manufacturing enough parts to keep up with demand and refused to recall the car.  I asked them to commit to replacing the remaining coil packs when they resolve their supply problems.  They refused.  VW finally sent a letter to notify their customers of the problem.

I was semi-disappointed in VW's response to the problem.  They made a good effort to manufacture more coils and offered to pay for rentals.  However, since they won't repair the remaining three defective coils or extend the warranty, I am not satisfied.  They were finally pushed to commit to fixing the problem after the Boston Globe, New York Times, and other media outlets started running negative stories.

Until I see a letter from them stating that they are going to replace the remaining 3 coils in my car that could fail at any time, I question their customer commitment.

2002 Passat Specs

Powertrain 
  170hp 1.8L DOHC 20 valve intercooled turbo I-4 engine with SMPI 
  Fuel Type: premium unleaded 
  Emissions Type: ULEV 
  5 speed manual transmission with overdrive 
  3.7 axle ratio 
  Front-wheel drive 
  Fuel Economy City: 22mpg 
  Fuel Economy Highway: 31mpg 
  Fuel Tank Capacity: 16.4gal. 
 
 Suspension/Handling 
  Front independent multi-link suspension with anti-roll bar, gas-pressurized shocks 
  Rear semi-independent torsion beam suspension with anti-roll bar, gas-pressurized shocks 
  Hydraulic power-assisted rack-pinion steering 
  Front and rear 15.0" x 7.00" silver alloy wheels 
  P195/65R15.0 H BSW AS front and rear tires 
 
 Body Exterior 
  Driver and passenger power remote door mirrors 
  Body-colored door mirrors 
  Body-colored bumpers 
  Roof rack rails only 
  Body-colored bodyside moldings 
  Clearcoat paint 
 
 Convenience 
  Manual air conditioning 
  Express open/close glass sunroof 
  Cruise control 
  Power windows with driver and passenger 1-touch down/up (operable from the driver seat only) 
  Remote power door locks with 2 stage unlock and illuminated entry 
  Manual tilt/telescopic steering wheel 
  Day-night rearview mirror 
  Front and rear cupholders 
  Dual visor vanity mirrors 
  Full floor console 
  Covered floor storage 
  Driver and passenger door bins 
 
 Seats and Trim 
  Seating capacity of 5 
  Front bucket seats 
  6-way driver seat adjustment 
  Manual driver lumbar support 
  6-way passenger seat adjustment 
  Manual passenger lumbar support 
  Center front armrest 
  60-40 folding rear bench seat 
  Premium cloth seat upholstery 
 
 Entertainment Features 
  AM/FM stereo radio 
  Auto-reverse cassette 
  Single CD player 
  8 speakers 
  Integrated roof antenna 
 
 Lighting, Visibility and Instrumentation 
  Halogen projector beam headlights 
  Front fog lights 
  Variable intermittent front windshield wipers 
  Speed sensitive wipers 
  Fixed interval rear windshield wiper 
  Rear window defroster 
  Fixed rear 1/4 vent windows 
  Front and rear reading lights 
  Light tinted windows 
  Tachometer 
  Outside temperature display 
  Trip computer 
  Trip odometer 
 
 Safety and Security 
  4-wheel ABS brakes 
  4-wheel disc brakes 
  ABS and driveline traction control 
  Dual front impact airbags 
  Dual seat mounted side impact airbags 
  Overhead airbags 
  Airbag occupancy sensor 
  Power remote door locks with 2 stage unlock and panic alarm 
  Security system with Transponder III ignition disable 
  Manually adjustable front head restraints with tilt 
  3 manually adjustable rear head restraints with tilt 
 
 Specs and Dimensions 
  Engine displacement: 1.8L 
  Engine horsepower: 170hp @ 5900RPM 
  Engine torque: 166 lb.-ft. @ 1950RPM 
  Curb weight: 1,514kg (3,338lbs) 
  Front legroom: 1,054.1mm (41.5") 
  Rear legroom: 896.6mm (35.3") 
  Front headroom: 960.1mm (37.8") 
  Rear headroom: 962.7mm (37.9") 
  Front shoulder room: 1,417.3mm (55.8") 
  Rear shoulder room: 1,386.8mm (54.6") 
  Passenger volume: 2,633 L (93.0 cu.ft.) 
  Exterior length: 4,681.2mm (184.3") 
  Exterior body width: 1,745.0mm (68.7") 
  Exterior height: 1,498.6mm (59.0") 
  Wheelbase: 2,702.6mm (106.4") 
  Turning radius: 5.7m (18.7') 
 
 Limited Warranty 
  Bumper to bumper limited warranty:48 months/50,000miles (whichever occurs first) 
  Major components limited warranty:60 months/60,000miles (whichever occurs first) 
  Corrosion perforation limited warranty:144 months/ unlimited distance (whichever occurs first)